Comparing Matt Varnishes: Which One Doesn't Frost? Our Ultimate Test
Comparing Matt Varnishes: Which One Doesn't Frost? Our Ultimate Test
Meta Description: Avoid the heartbreak of frosted miniatures! We tested the top matt varnishes to find which one provides a perfect, durable, and crystal-clear finish every time. Read before you varnish!
There's no feeling quite like it. You've spent dozens of hours painstakingly painting your masterpiece miniature. You carefully apply a matt varnish to protect your work and unify the finish. And then you see it: a horrible, white, chalky haze has descended over your model. Frosting. It's the nightmare of every miniature painter. But not all varnishes are created equal. We took the most popular brands into the lab (our hobby desk) to put them to the ultimate test: which matt varnish truly delivers a crystal-clear, durable finish without the dreaded frost?
The Frosting Culprit: Why Does It Happen?
Before the results, it's crucial to understand the enemy. Frosting is usually caused by one of two things:
High Humidity: Applying varnish in humid conditions causes microscopic moisture droplets to get trapped in the drying varnish, scattering light and creating a white, frosted appearance.
Poor Formulation: Some varnishes are simply more susceptible to frosting due to their chemical makeup, even in ideal conditions. They can dry cloudy or develop a haze over time.
Our test aimed to find a varnish that fights both causes.
The Test: Methodology
To keep things fair, we:
Painted identical test miniatures with a variety of textures and colors.
Applied each varnish according to its manufacturer's instructions.
Tested in controlled conditions (~50% humidity, 70°F / 21°C) AND in a stress test (higher humidity).
Evaluated on three criteria: Clarity (no frosting), Finish (true matt), and Durability.
The Varnishes: Ranked from Worst to Best
4. Army Painter Anti-Shine Matt Varnish (Spray)
Performance: Unfortunately, this was the most inconsistent. In our humidity stress test, it frosted significantly. Even in good conditions, the finish can be slightly satin rather than a dead flat matt. It also felt slightly tacky to the touch after curing.
Verdict: ❌ High Risk. We cannot recommend this for valuable models due to its volatility and tendency to frost.
3. Citadel Munitorum Varnish (Spray)
Performance: A decent middle-of-the-road option. When applied perfectly in ideal weather, it provides a good, durable matt finish. However, it has a known reputation for being very sensitive to humidity and can frost if you spray even a little too heavily. The margin for error is small.
Verdict: ⚠️ Use with Caution. Only use this on a perfect day, and always test on a spare piece first. Not worth the risk on a centerpiece model.
2. AK Interactive Ultra Matt Varnish (Liquid)
Performance: This is the king of the ultra-matt finish. It eliminates all shine completely, giving a almost chalky, realistic feel that is perfect for historical models or cloth. It's highly resistant to frosting. The downside? It must be airbrushed. Brushing it on can lead to visible streaks.
Verdict: ✅ Excellent (For Airbrush Users). If you own an airbrush and want the flattest finish possible, this is your winner. It's incredibly reliable.
1. Vallejo Mecha Color Matt Varnish (Liquid)
Performance: The undisputed champion for frosting resistance. Formulated for model kits that undergo handling, its polymers are designed to remain perfectly clear. It can be brushed or airbrushed with flawless results. It delivered a perfect, durable, crystal-clear matt finish in both our ideal and stress tests. It is specifically designed to resist humidity-related frosting.
Verdict: ✅ Highly Recommended. This is the most reliable and safest choice for the average hobbyist. Its versatility (brush-on) and bulletproof performance make it our top pick.
Pro Application Tips to Avoid Frosting (Even with Good Varnish)
Check the Humidity: Don't varnish if the humidity is above 70%. If you must, work in short bursts indoors with climate control.
Shake, Don't Stir: Shake your varnish can for at least 2-3 minutes. For liquid varnish, stir it gently to avoid introducing bubbles.
Warm the Can: Before shaking, place the spray can in a bowl of lukewarm water for a few minutes. This improves aerosolization and prevents a spotty application.
Thin Coats are Key: Apply 2-3 thin, misting coats from a distance of 20-30 cm (8-12 inches), allowing time to dry between each. One thick coat is a recipe for disaster.
The Brushing Advantage: Using a brush-on varnish like Vallejo Mecha Matt completely eliminates the risk of humidity-related frosting, giving you total control.
6 FAQs About Matt Varnishes and Frosting
Conclusion: And the Winner Is...
After rigorous testing, the crown for the most reliable, frost-resistant matt varnish goes to Vallejo Mecha Color Matt Varnish.
Its foolproof formulation works brilliantly whether brushed or airbrushed, it delivers a perfectly clear and durable matt finish, and it stands up to less-than-ideal conditions that would ruin other varnishes. For airbrush users seeking the absolute flattest finish, AK Interactive Ultra Matt is a phenomenal choice.
The best way to avoid frosting is to use a high-quality varnish and apply it correctly. Don't let the fear of frosting stop you from protecting your beautiful paint jobs. With the right product in your arsenal, you can seal your models with confidence.
Post a Comment