The Best Substitutes for Expensive Hobby Glues (Tested & Ranked)
The Best Substitutes for Expensive Hobby Glues (Tested & Ranked)
Meta Description: Is Citadel Plastic Glue worth the price? We tested cheap super glues, PVA, and more to find the best budget-friendly alternatives for model building and miniature painting.
https://i.imgur.com/placeholder.png Why spend $8 on a tiny bottle of glue when a $2 one works just as well? We did the science so you don't have to.
Glue is glue, right? Then why does that tiny pot of Citadel Plastic Glue cost as much as a large sandwich? As hobbyists, we often pay a premium for branding and packaging, assuming it’s necessary for quality.
I call bluff. I went to the hardware store, the pharmacy, and the supermarket and put every cheap adhesive I could find to the test. The results were shocking.
Here’s my ranked list of the best budget glue substitutes for every hobby task.
1. For Plastic-to-Plastic: Super Glue Gel vs. Plastic Cement
The Hobby Standard: Polystyrene Cement (Tamiya Extra Thin, Citadel Plastic Glue). This isn't actually a glue; it's a welding agent that melts the plastic pieces together into a permanent bond.
The Best Budget Substitute: Super Glue Gel (Cyanoacrylate).
Brands: Gorilla Super Glue Gel, Loctite Ultra Gel Control.
Why it wins: The gel formula is king. It doesn’t run, gives you time to position parts, and creates an incredibly strong, durable bond on plastic, resin, and metal. For most building tasks, it’s actually better than liquid cement because it doesn't require clamping for long periods.
Cost: A 3-pack of Gorilla Gel is often cheaper than one small bottle of Tamiya Extra Thin.
Verdict: 10/10. This is the ultimate all-purpose, value-for-money champion.
2. For Pinning & Strong Bonds: Two-Part Epoxy
The Hobby Standard: Specialty two-part epoxy putties or super-strong hobby-branded epoxies.
The Best Budget Substitute: Generic Two-Part Epoxy from a Hardware Store.
Why it wins: For pinning heavy metal models or repairing a priceless antique kit, nothing beats the sheer strength of a proper 5-minute or 30-minute epoxy. It fills gaps and creates a bond that is often stronger than the material itself.
Verdict: 9/10. A must-have for heavy-duty jobs, and a large tube costs the same as a tiny hobby version.
3. For Clear Parts & Basing: PVA White Glue
The Hobby Standard: “Clear Parts” glue or basing glue.
The Best Budget Substitute: PVA White Glue (Elmer’s School Glue).
Why it wins: It’s perfect for two things:
Clear Parts: It dries transparent and flexible, so it won’t frost clear canopies like super glue can.
Basing: It’s the ideal, non-toxic adhesive for sand, static grass, and flock. You can water it down for easier application.
Verdict: 10/10. There is literally zero reason to ever buy a branded version of this.
4. For Temporary Holds: Poster Putty
The Hobby Standard: Expensive “poster tack” or “holding putty” sold in hobby stores.
The Best Budget Substitute: Blue Tack or White Tack.
Why it wins: It’s the exact same product for a fraction of the price. Use it to temporarily hold parts for painting, test-fit assemblies, or stick a miniature to a paint pot as a handle.
Verdict: 10/10. The definition of a rebranded product. Buy the cheap stuff.
What to AVOID:
Hot Glue Guns: The bond is weak and the glue blobs are too bulky for fine detail work.
Household Goop (e.g., E6000): While strong, it’s too stringy and messy for precision model work. The fumes are also intense.
School Glue Sticks: Not strong enough for any structural work.
The Thrifty Painter's Final Verdict
You can kit out your entire workshop with top-tier adhesives for less than the cost of two bottles of branded glue.
My essential, budget-friendly glue kit consists of:
Super Glue Gel (for 95% of all building)
PVA White Glue (for basing and clear parts)
Poster Putty (for temporary holds)
Stop overpaying. Your wallet—and your models—will thank you.
What’s your go-to budget glue? Have you found a hidden gem? Share your tips in the comments below!
Post a Comment